Friday, August 06, 2004

Canadian Bacon Anyone?....


Russ Ford : The Right Scuff


People would never look at an emery board the same way again.



When people think of New York’s American League franchise as respects pitchers named Ford -- generally the name first called to mind is Whitey. However long before the Yankees even made "Yankees" their official nickname they had another spectacular arm, a righthander named Russ Ford. Born Russell William Ford in Brandon Manitoba, Canada, Ford would light up the Yankees’ horizon as briefly and brilliantly as a bolt of chain lightning.



Ford made his major league debut in 1909 pitching a three inning relief appearance. His rocky outing where he surrendered three earned runs, four hits and four bases on balls gave absolutely no indication of what was to come.



Russ Ford : Chairman of the [emery] Board



In 1910, at age 27, Ford would set the American League on its ear. The spitball was then a legal pitch in professional baseball. Ford however had developed a new twist on the tricky pitch. The difficulty in throwing the spitter is that it generally requires applying a foreign substance to the baseball. However in doing so, the ball becomes difficult to grip and control because of the resulting slickness/stickiness.


Ford however bypassed that difficulty by not applying any of the standard forms of goop to the baseball but rather altering the surface of the ball itself. Using an emery board he was able to doctor the baseball in such a way that he could increase the action of a pitch without sacrificing grip or control. With this new wrinkle in place Ford, despite a late start to his career, would put together a season that would set several Yankee records.


In 1910, Philadelphia Athletics’ owner/manager Connie Mack had finished assembling on of baseball’s all time greatest teams. The Athletics would cop the America League flag that year, four pennants over the next five years with three World Series championships. This was the team against which Russ Ford made his major league starting debut. Ford threw a five-hitter downing the embryonic dynasty 1-0.


Over the course of that summer Ford would show that his debut was not a fluke. He enjoyed a 12 game winning streak over the course of that summer as his "emery pitch" danced, dipped and dropped around American League batsmen. One of the more memorable moments of the 1910 campaign was a game against the Cleveland Naps. As good as Ford was, he knew it was prudent not to let a team’s best hitter beat him. Three times he tried to walk Naps’ second baseman Nap Lajoie. Three times Lajoie got a hit. In Lajoie’s fourth at bat he got three balls on the future Hall of Famer but could not get ball four past him as he fouled off pitch after pitch. Finally Ford put the pitch where even Lajoie could not reach it, throwing the ball three feet behind him.


The Highlanders/Yankees continued to pursue the Athletics throughout the summer months. Ford put together a remarkable September winning seven games that month while losing none. However the Athletics would not be caught and despite Ford’s heroics; Philadelphia would not be headed. Ford would finish the regular season 26-6 and added seven additional shutouts onto the one he pitched against the Athletics in his starting debut.


The New York Giants, like the Highlanders/Yankees, finished second in their league. A seven-game city series was arranged between both New York clubs. This was historic in that it was the first series between the Giants and the Highlander/Yankees. In the opener at the Polo Grounds Ford faced Giants ace Christy Mathewson who had finished 27-9 that year. For 7 1/2 innings it was a tight game, but in the last of the eighth, two costly Yankee errors and a hit batsman and four Giant base hits, broke open a 1-1 tie with four runs for a Giant victory.


The 1911 campaign was uneventful for the New York American League club. Ford, showing no evidence of a "sophomore jinx," finished 22-11 on a .500 team as the Highlanders/Yankees finished 76-76. Both Ford’s and his team’s fortunes plummeted the following year as they finished dead last in the league even behind the moribund St. Louis Browns. Ford became one of a handful of pitchers who would go from winning over twenty games (22-11 in 1911) to losing 20-plus the following campaign (13-21 in 1912).


Ford righted himself in 1913 as his club continued to flounder. A 12-18 record obscured that he had pitched rather well. The only thing that went right for New York that year was they managed to finish slightly ahead of the Browns but still could not crack the sixty win barrier. Ford’s earned run average that year was 2.66 whereas the American League average was 2.93.


A Final Hurrah



During this time there were rumblings throughout baseball about the possibility of a third major league. In 1913 the Federal League was born. In 1914, the league proclaimed itself a "major league" and started raiding major league rosters of name players. The generous contracts offered by this upstart league caused many players to jump from the majors to this infant circuit. Ford decided to "follow the money," signed with the Federal League and assigned to Buffalo. Ford emerged as one of the league’s top hurlers.



The inaugural season of the Federal League (as a "major league") featured the weakest pitching among the three circuits. Ford stood tall winning 21 losing 6 with an ERA of 1.82 when the league average [for ERA] was 3.20. However he scuffled the following season going a meager 5-9, 4.52 ERA. It was his final major league season.



He no longer had his good scuff.



Other scuff of interest.....


  • Although his tenure with the Yankees was brief, he still owns the best ERA in team history (2.54).

  • Ford was the first Canadian pitcher in baseball history to have a 20-win season.

  • Ford batted .209 lifetime.

  • Ford held the Yankee single season record for shutouts (8) until broken by Ron Guidry in 1978.

  • Ford’s .813 winning percentage set in 1910 stood as a Yankee record until broken by Lefty Gomez in 1934.

  • Ford is one of five Yankee hurlers to win five or more games after September 1. The other four are Ernie Bonham, Mel Stottlemyre, Bob Wickman and Andy Pettite.

  • Ty Cobb hit .520 lifetime against Ford.


Best Regards


John



Sunday, August 01, 2004

Now that was a trade deadline. Lots of controversy, big names changing big teams, cheers of joy, rending of garments in lamentation....everything you could’ve wanted. I’ve got a few thoughts, a wee bit of analysis, and even some unsolicited advice.


First off....some of the notable deals:


  • Red Sox: Acquired shortstop Orlando Cabrera from the Montreal Expos for infielders Alex Gonzalez and Brendan Harris and pitcher Francis Beltran; acquired outfielder Dave Roberts from the Los Angeles Dodgers for outfielder Henri Stanley.
  • Cubs: Acquired first baseman Doug Mientkiewicz from the Minnesota Twins for pitcher Justin Jones; acquired shortstop Nomar Garciaparra, outfielder Matt Murton and cash considerations from the Boston Red Sox for Mientkiewicz, infielders Alex Gonzalez and Brendan Harris and pitcher Francis Beltran.
  • Twins: Acquired minor league pitcher Justin Jones.
  • Expos: Acquired Alex Gonzalez, pitcher Francis Beltran and infielder Brendan Harris
  • White Sox: Acquired pitcher Jose Contreras and cash considerations from the New York Yankees for pitcher Esteban Loaiza.
  • Dodgers: Acquired outfielder Steve Finley and catcher Brent Mayne from the Arizona Diamondbacks for catcher Koyie Hill, pitcher Bill Murphy and outfielder Reggie Abercrombie. Acquired pitchers Brad Penny and Bill Murphy and first baseman Hee Seop Choi from the Florida Marlins for catcher Paul Lo Duca, outfielder Juan Encarnacion and pitcher Guillermo Mota.
  • Marlins: Acquired pitcher Rudy Seanez from the Kansas City Royals for outfielder Abraham Nunez; acquired pitcher Ismael Valdez from the San Diego Padres for pitcher Travis Chick. Acquired catcher Paul Lo Duca, outfielder Juan Encarnacion and pitcher Guillermo Mota from the Dodgers for pitchers Brad Penny and Bill Murphy and first baseman Hee Seop Choi from the Florida Marlins.
  • Mets: Acquired infielder Jose Bautista from the Kansas City Royals for catcher Justin Huber; acquired pitcher Kris Benson and infielder Jeff Keppinger from the Pittsburgh Pirates for Bautista, infielder Ty Wigginton and pitcher Matt Peterson; acquired pitchers Victor Zambrano and Bartolome Fortunato from the Tampa Bay Devil Rays for pitchers Scott Kazmir and Jose Diaz

I’ve been reading Sons of Sam Horn and came across this sentiment from a poster there on the deal that sent icon Nomar Garciaparra to the Cubs: “Only game I have interest in going to at Fenway this year is Mon. Sept 9 vs TB. Their first game home and our first chance to go boo the @#%$ out of Cabrera, Minkwhateverowitz and the bosox management.”


Bad idea, to anyone who shares the sentiment. If you want to jeer the management team--fine. But this trade wasn’t Cabrera’s or Mientkiewicz’s idea and it wasn’t their fault. They’re gonna bust their butts to win the Red Sox the pennant and deserve support. Losing a superstar like Garciaparra is almost always painful, but don’t forget who’s responsible for the trade, and who isn’t. Blaming the players acquired in the deal accomplishes nothing. The Red Sox probably were going to lose Nomar to free agency and due to the money Garciaparra’s making in 2004 ($11.5 million), the Red Sox might not have offered arbitration (the Red Sox would pay a minimum of $9.2 million and you can bet that if the Red Sox were to offer anything under what Garciaparra made this year they‘d probably lose in arbitration). So, instead of losing Garciaparra and getting *nothing* in return, the Red Sox traded two months of Nomar and got two Gold Glovers to shore up a weak defense.


Other things to bear in mind: Garciaparra is going to want a big contract (I’m guessing 5 years/ $75 million). He’s been fragile, his defense is declining, and he’s on the wrong side of 30. So whomever signs him to his next contract is going to find out all about “the winner‘s curse.” The Red Sox got the best of Nomar Garciaparra at half the cost of Alex Rodriguez. Now somebody else is going to pay for his decline phase. Also, the Red Sox were dealing with an unhappy, injured superstar who can't play SS effectively anymore on a good offensive team with plenty of defensive question marks. Chances are Cabrera and Mientkiewicz have a better shot at rediscovering their offense than Garciaparra has of rediscovering his range and health.


Just remember the hosing the Mariners took when their icon--Ken Griffey Jr.--wanted out. Everybody said that the Mariners were doomed forever and the Reds may as well print World Series tickets. The Mariners went to the post season the first two years after Junior departed and won 93 games in each of the two seasons after that. The Reds ended up with $116.5 million albatross.


In short, the weeping and the gnashing of teeth in Boston might be a bit premature. Don’t forget, the Red Sox are a distant second in the AL East, and second in the wild card standings. The status quo may not have gotten it done. I’m not saying the Red Sox made a terrific deal, but all things considered, it wasn’t a horrible one either.


Now the Mets. These were horrible deals. They cashed in the 2005, 2006, 2007, and 2008 seasons for a futile shot at a title in 2004. The Mets are 49-54, fourth place in the NL East, eight games back, and even further back in the wild card hunt. Kris Benson had one season where he tossed more than 200 IP (2000) and Victor Zambrano seems to challenge Barry Bonds for walk totals in a season. For this (and others) they gave up Justin Huber, Ty Wigginton, Matt Peterson, Scott Kazmir and Jose Diaz? I’m not a Mets fan but I’m flabbergasted. If the Blue Jays get healthy, the Devil Rays will make the 2005 AL East a real dogfight with the additions of Diaz and Kazmir. I do not know the thought processes that went into this deal. Somebody’s head(s) should roll. For disappointed Red Sox fans--this is what a bad deal looks like. Everything the Mets had been building towards has just been depth charged into oblivion.


Although I think the Dodgers got the better end of the deal with the Marlins, I think both teams got what they were looking for. The Dodgers upgraded both the present and the future with the additions of Penny, Choi, and Murphy, and the Fish bolstered their bullpen and the difference in their offense should be negligible. The Marlins made this deal with 2004 in mind and did what championship teams are sometimes forced to do--trade away some of the future for a shot at the present. The Marlins are the defending World Series champions and are still close enough to the NL East title to take a run at a repeat. The Dodgers on the other hand just made Brian Sabean look comatose. Granted, Sabean may have been handcuffed by Magowan . The Giants are only 4.5 games out of the NL West and two games out of the wild card. The Giants should’ve been more active but chose not to. Finally, although I feel the Expos’ days are numbered, they picked up some good prospects for a player on the way out. I just wish I could enjoy it more, but for Expos’ fans, the future never comes.


Best Regards


John

Friday, June 25, 2004

Well this was different, I actually was threatened with bodily harm if I didn't update my blog. So in the interests of personal safety I figured I'd best take my keyboard out and do something with it.


This time--1950-59:


*1950*


Well, it's cheaper than hiring better players....


The St. Louis Browns hire hypnotist David Tracy to cure Brownies of defeatist attitude.


I guess they didn't count on the Red Sox on snapping their fingers....


On June 8, the Red Sox spank the Browns 29-4 at Fenway Park.


Great! Now we can afford to sign a situational lefty that *every* team can use!....


TV provides $2.3M in revenue for MLB.


Could you explain the rule to me again?....


MLB institutes a new balk rule. Vic Raschi of the Yankees commits four balks on May 3.


Moneybonehead....


White Sox pitcher Bill Wight gets no hits, and four walks, and 17 strikeouts in 61 at bats giving him an AVG/OBP/SLG/OPS of: .000/.062/.000/.062.


Did he dump ice water on Mel Allen's head?


Jackie Jensen of the Phillies plays in both the Rose Bowl and the Fall Classic.


How to skewer your stats for the month....chapter i pg. i ¶ i


Gil Hodges blasts four HR in a game on the last day of August.


Road worriers....


The A's allow almost seven runs per game away from Shibe Park.


No doubt the A's were helpful in setting this record....


The Red Sox score 625 runs at Fenway Park.


And they did it again against the Blue Jays bullpen in a May game in 2004....


The Red Sox score 216 runs against the St. Louis Browns.


Early to bed Early to rise makes your ERA go sky high....


Early Wynn wins the AL ERA crown with a 3.20 mark.


Some guys just can't seen to hold on to a regular job....


Red Sox supersub Billy Goodman wins the AL batting crown (.354); Goodman plays over 20 games each at the infield corners, 45 games in the outfield, and sees time at both keystone positions.


Watch Bud Selig's head explode....


Four teams in the AL win 90 games. New York: 98-56, Detroit: 95-59, Boston: 94-60, and Cleveland: 92-62. Fifth place Washington finishes 67-87, 25 games out of fourth place.


And they invented some new swear words....


The Cleveland Indians finish fourth place in the American League with a 92-62 record; better than NL pennant winner Philadelphia Phillies' 91-63 ledger.


*1951*


Little Mr. Smug Mug....


St. Louis Browns Ned Garver goes 20-12, 3.73 ERA as the Brownies go 52-102.


How to suck....chapter i pg. i ¶ i


All pitchers who logged over 100 IP on the Browns walk more hitters than they strike out. Garver, Tommy Byrne, Duane Pillette, and Al Widmar walk 377 while striking out just 234.


In one of the innings the infield stayed in the dugout and nobody noticed....


Tommy Byrne who was traded to the Yankees walked 16 in a 13 inning game on August 22.


Why don't you go talk to Tim Wakefield Ralph and you can enjoy a good cry....


The Dodgers lose the NL flag to the Giants on Bobby Thomson's "shot heard around the world." It's the third time in six years that the Dodgers lost the pennant on the last day of the season.


*1952*


The Little Hoyt....


New York Giants pitcher Hoyt Wilhelm homers in his first MLB at bat on April 23. He never hit another dinger--his career ended in 1972.


Another record the Jays bullpen is shooting for....


On May 21, in the first inning, 19 straight Dodger hitters reach base against the Reds.


Maybe the infielders and outfielders could've brought a good book instead of their gloves....


Ron Necciai of the Appalachian League throws a no-hitter while striking out 27 on June 13.


The rest were killed by the AL....


Bob Neighbors of the Browns becomes the only major leaguer to be killed while fighting in Korea.


Heck, Jesse Orosco is still a young buck....


Satchel Paige throws a 12-inning shutout against the Tigers on August 6--he is 47 at the time.


Empty victory....


The Indians have three 20-game winners, the league leader in HR and RBI, and lead the loop in runs, runs produced, slugging percentage, triples, IP, and CG but still finish two games behind the Yankees.


What the Truck is going on?....


Tiger hurler Virgil Trucks goes 5-19, 3.97 ERA. Two of his five wins are no-hitters and a third is a one-hitter.


Rockin' Robin....


Robin Roberts wins 28 games. He goes 3-3 against the Giants, 2-2 against the Cubs, and 23-2 against everybody else.


Of course *everybody* dumps on Expo fans....


The Boston Braves draw just 281,278 for the season.


*1953*


Bobo job....


Brownie Bobo Holloman throws a no-hitter in his first major league start on May 6. He'll win two more games in 1953 and be out of baseball by 1954.


The more things change....


Paul Pettit, the Pirates $100,000 "Bonus Baby" wins his only major league game. Indians $100,000 "Bonus Baby" -- Billy Joe Davidson -- never even makes it to the big leagues.


Didn't Cito Gaston let something similar happen to Mike Timlin to help build his confidence?....


On June 18, the Red Sox almost bat around three times (23 hitters) and score 17 runs. Gene Stephens gets a modern record three hits in the inning.


Home schnookin'....


The Browns lose 20 straight at home.


[you know you who are] take note....


Al Rosen loses the triple crown when he doesn't beat out a ground ball in his last at bat of the season.


*1954*


In Soviet Russia cock smacks you around....


The Braves' Joe Adcock rips 4 HR and a double for 18 total bases on August 1.


Didn't Cito Gaston let something similar happen to Tony Castillo to help build his confidence?....


On August 8, the Dodgers score 12 runs with two out and nobody on.


Pipp squeak....


Braves OF (and hero the 1951 Giants) Bobby Thomson's injury causes the Braves to replace him with former Negro Leaguer Henry Aaron.


If he'd driven in 150 runs per year they might've had him shot....


The Cardinals' Ray Jablonski begins his career with consecutive 100 RBI seasons. He's dealt to Cincinnati at the end of the season.


The reason you've never heard about this before is because of a government conspiracy and cover-up....


Longhorn Leaguer Joe Bauman hits 72 home runs playing while for Roswell


Have you ever wondered who Joe Carter had on the baseball poster hanging in his bedroom?....


Gil Hodges of the Dodgers sets a record with 19 sac flies.


Winning a pennant is as easy as 1-2-3....


Tribe pitchers Mike Garcia, Bob Lemon, and Early Wynn finish 1-2-3 in AL ERA.


*1955*


Pitch count? What's that?....


Rookie "Toothpick Sam" Jones of the Cubs walks 185 and whiffs 198 in 242 IP.


If nothing else, he's exciting....


The same Sam Jones -- in the midst of a no-hitter -- walks the bases full then strikes out the side in the ninth inning.


Relieving yourself at the plate....


Tigers' reliever Babe Birrer (4-3, 3 SV, 4.16 ERA) hits home runs in both his at bats in a four inning relief stint on July 19.


*1956*


Dale Long-ball....


The Pirates' Dale Long homers in eight consecutive games.


Sometimes changing the pitcher involves Pampers and wet-naps....


Jim Derrington of the White Sox becomes the youngest pitcher to start a big-league game. His pitching line: 6 IP, 9 H, 6 R, 5 ER, 6 BB, 3 K. He was 16 at the time.


Ya think?....


Troy Herriage goes 1-13, 6.64 ERA for the Kansas City A's. It's his only ML season.


Why batting average is a dumb stat....


Eddie Yost garners just 119 hits and bats .231. His OBP is .412 after drawing a staggering 151 walks.


This is the only thing the 2004 Blue Jays have in common with the 1956 Yankees....


On September 21, the Yanks leave 20 men on base in a nine inning game against the Red Sox.


*1957*


You again?....


Ted Williams reaches base 16 times in 16 at bats.


Have you ever wondered why Curt Flood didn't want to go to Philadelphia?....


The Phillies finally have an African American player on the major league roster--3B John Kennedy (he received two at bats that year).


Well, it's because they all sucked....


The Kansas City A's don't have a single pitcher with enough IP to qualify for an ERA title as 14 different pitchers make starts.


We're all impressed, but let's see if you can prove it wasn't a fluke....


Pitcher Bob Riesener of the Evangeline League posts a perfect 20-0 record.


What's so amazing is that he pitched half his starts in one of the best pitchers' park in the American League....


Pete Ramos of the Washington Senators serves up a then-record 43 HR. Oddly enough, the current record was set by a pitcher who played for the transplanted Senators in Minnesota in 1987 (Bert Blyleven coughed up 50 in an excellent *hitters'* park).


Like a herd of turtles....


The Washington Senators steal just 13 bases.


*1958*


Youneverknow....


Vic Power steals three bases all season. Two of them were steals of home on August 14.


The first time is the most memorable--especially if you only do it ONE FRICKIN' TIME!!!!....


On September 20, Hoyt Wilhelm who homered in his first ML at bat in 1953 throws a no-hitter in his first major league *start* against the 1958 World Series champ New York Yankees.


*1959*


The ball wasn't loaded by the infield was....


The White Sox score 11 runs on one hit in the seventh inning against Kansas City on April 22.


If "Shoeless Joe" named his bat "Black Betsy," do you think his bat was named Adrienne?....


On June 10, Rocky Colavito slugs four HR.


Don't pinch me....


Oriole Dave Philley collects pinch hits in nine straight games.


Have you ever wondered why Sparky Anderson was fixated with using Milt Cuyler?....


In 477 at bats, the Phillies' Sparky Anderson garners just 119 total bases and has an OPS of .531 (NL OPS: .754, NL OPS for 2B: .686).


The Blue Jays couldn't get this many in a year....


On September 22, the Dodgers collect nine pinch hits.


Although Tampa Bay can make your bullpen sick too, that's not what TB stood for....


The Braves possibly lose the pennant when Red Schoendienst contracts TB and lost for the season.


Best Regards


John



Thursday, May 13, 2004

On Baseball Primer, there’s been a discussion about Edgar Martinez’s chances for the Hall-of-Fame. Of course, the big millstone around his neck is the fact that he’s played a good chunk of his career as a designated hitter.


I think there’s a number of compelling reasons why Martinez should be a lock. Some examples:


The greatest first, second and third baseman, shortstop, left, right and centerfielder, the greatest pitcher and catcher are all in the Hall-of-Fame. So doesn’t it stand to reason that the greatest DH should be there as well?


Is he the greatest DH? He is and it’s not close. Let’s use two objective measures: Runs Created Above Average (RCAA) and adjusted OPS+ since they take into consideration park effects and league averages while adjusted OPS+ also takes eras into account.


Using RCAA, Edgar Martinez is first all time with 532 (through the end of 2003). Paul Molitor is second with 279! Using adjusted OPS+ Martinez is second with a mark of 151. Frank Thomas is first at 162 although it should be noted that “The Big Hurt” has DHed in 867 games as opposed to Martinez’s 1290 [games]. Thomas has just 269 RCAA as a DH....almost half of Martinez’s total.


Let’s toss out the DH and look at Martinez’s career totals (through the end of 2003):


  • RCAA: 665. He’s 24th all time. Among eligible players, everybody above him is in the HOF. Those who aren’t in Cooperstown are considered locks: Barry Bonds, Rickey Henderson, Frank Thomas, and Mark McGwire. Below Martinez (among the top 100 in RCAA since 1900) are 37 Hall-of-Famers. Also among the top 100 [below Martinez] are several players who have strong cases for the Hall: Jeff Bagwell, Wade Boggs, Rafael Palmeiro, Tim Raines, Ken Griffey Jr., Tony Gwynn, Joe Jackson, Pete Rose (well, they would if it weren‘t for poor life choices), Mike Piazza, Alex Rodriguez, and Roberto Alomar as well as players who are getting close to Cooperstown credentials: Gary Sheffield, Fred McGriff, Jim Thome, Manny Ramirez, Jason Giambi, Chipper Jones, and Craig Biggio. suffice it to say, he wouldn’t be ratcheting down the standards for Hall-of-Fame induction.
  • His current adjusted OPS+ is good for 32nd all time and he’s got Hall-of-Famers, or soon to be Hall-of-Famers around him. Those above him that aren’t enshrined suffer from banishment (Joe Jackson), short careers (Pete Browning, David Orr, and Charlie Keller....Orr and Browning are also hurt by being 19th century players), or for alleged character issues (Dick Allen). Granted Martinez’s RCAA and adjusted OPS+ is subject to some erosion, but he’s 41 years old and has close to 7000 AB on his resume which means his decline will come swiftly and he probably won’t stick around long enough to see significant decline time.
  • Martinez’s OBP is .422 as of this writing, good for 17th all time. His SLG is .522....good for 54th all time.
  • What some feel to be potential downfalls are his counting stats and his being a DH. Let’s address these. I’m going to cheat a little here and go quick and dirty because, well, I’m lazy (yeah, yeah, the more the qualifiers, the fewer the bodies, but I‘ll make a point about it later). Here’s the benchmark: players with careers of 2000 hits, 500 doubles, 300 HR, 1000 runs/RBI/BB that batted .300 lifetime. The following are those who qualify: Babe Ruth, Ted Williams, Lou Gehrig, Rogers Hornsby, Stan Musial, Hank Aaron, George Brett, Mel Ott, Willie Mays, and Edgar Martinez. Now it’s pretty obvious that one of these things is not like the other. If you read Bill James, you can find some major flaws in this comparison, but my reason for doing it is this: to accomplish 2000 hits, 500 doubles, 300 HR, 1000 runs/RBI/BB and batting .300 lifetime you need the following skills--you have to be able to hit for average, you have to be able to hit for power, you have to have a keen batting eye and you have to sustain it for a significant period of time. That’s why only 10 players have accomplished the feat in major league history, it takes a special kind of hitter to accomplish it. Some forgettable players have high batting averages (Riggs Stephenson .336), tons of hits (Doc Cramer 2705 hits), HR totals (Dave Kingman 442 HR), 2B totals (Al Oliver 529 2B) lots of RBI (Joe Carter 1445 RBI), high walk totals (Eddie Yost 1614 BB), plenty of runs scored (Tom Brown 1521 runs), but to excel in all the aforementioned categories is reserved for the truly great. In other words, there’s nothing wrong with Edgar Martinez’s counting stats.
  • As to the DH issue, I’m going to resort to the “lowest common denominator” argument. We’ve already established that Martinez is a Hall-of-Fame hitter, but what about his lack of time in the field? Well, going to the opposite extreme, we need look no further than recent inductee Bill Mazeroski; a Hall-of-Fame defender? No doubt. What about his hitting? Yes, he had over 2000 hits but that’s it. Did you know he never had a single season where he was league average in OBP+SLG (OPS)? Not once. Every year, a league average hitter at second base would’ve been a better asset in the lineup than Maz. Yes, second base is a key defensive position, but how did Mazeroski fare against his contemporary second sackers? Over the course of his career, an average 2B created 834 runs. Maz created only 821 runs. In short, not only was he an offensive liability, he was an offensive liability for a second baseman! There are other examples of players inducted due to outstanding defense (Ozzie Smith, Rick Ferrell) and there are great offensive players inducted who were less-than-stellar with the leather (Harmon Killibrew, Hack Wilson). Why? It was felt that their respective deficiencies were far outweighed by their other contributions. It‘s no different for Edgar Martinez. Martinez’s deficiency (being a DH) is far outweighed by his offensive contributions.


I think he’s a deserving candidate.


Team owners cry, whine, and bellyache about the money they lose running their teams. A bran fed pachyderm with diarrhea produces less, um, smelly biological waste matter than an owner discussing team finances. They do it however because (i) they hope to convince the players to accept salary restrictions and (ii) they hope to con municipalities to build them lavish new stadiums so they can afford to overpay mediocrities while avoiding being forced to eat Fancy Feast out of the can with their fingers while they try to stay warm in their home which is the back seat of a rusted out 1972 Ford Pinto. Well, Field of Schemes is like the toilet paper needed to wipe out the crap that resides in the arsehole(s) running major league baseball. If you don't think Bud and Co. are more full of it than a prune free retirement village this site will change your mind. The book is pretty good too. If you're so inclined, join the mailing list--it's all good.


Best Regards


John

Friday, May 07, 2004

This time--1940-49:


*1940*


Anticlimactic....


On Opening Day, Bob Feller no-hits the White Sox.


Halitosis? Flatulence? Valedictorian of the Ty Cobb School of Charm?....


Willis Hudlin plays for four teams in the same year: Cleveland, St. Louis (Browns), New York (Giants), and Washington.


And you wonder why Philadelphia fans are so hostile....


The Phillies and Athletics both lose 100+ games.


Melonball?....


The Yankees' Frank Crosetti (career BA .245; career OBP .341) leads the AL in hit-by-pitches for the fifth consecutive year.


*1941*


Jose Hernandez doesn't last 77 minutes....


Lloyd Waner plays 77 consecutive games without striking out.


What the puck?....


Canadian Jeff Heath of the Indians is the first AL player to hit 20+ doubles/triples/home runs in the same year.


I wish the Blue Jays would quit trying to top this....


The St. Louis Browns strand 1334 baserunners.


And how was your day?....


On May 7, Reds SS Eddie Joost handles 19 chances.


Sixty years later and we're still not impressed....


Danny Murtaugh of the Phillies leads the NL in steals (18), but hits just .219.


*1942*


I don't care if he's throwin' grapefruit--he's stayin' in....


On May 13, Braves' pitcher Jim Tobin blasts three HR.


War is hell....


Cardinals rookie Johnny Beazley goes 21-6, 2.13 ERA, enters the armed forces and never pitches effectively after his return (9-6, 4.39 ERA from 1946-49).


Neifi Perez x 8 =....


The Phillies drive in just 354 runs. Danny Litwhiler leads the club with 56 RBI. They also score just 394. Their team OPS? .593.


He was a two-way player, for a Phillie....


Danny Litwhiler goes the whole season without committing an error.


Gimme the ball and leave me the hell alone....


White Sox Ted Lyons makes 20 starts, pitches 20 complete games, and goes 14-6.


Make mine a double....


The A's bang into seven double plays against the Yankees on August 14.


What do I have to do? Walk on water?....


Ted Williams hits .406 in 1941 and loses the MVP to Joe DiMaggio. In 1942 he wins the Triple Crown and loses the MVP to the Yankees' Joe Gordon.


Somebody up there (the press box?) loves me!....


MVP Joe Gordon leads the AL in errors, strikeouts, and grounding into double plays.


*1943*


Of course modern baseball never experiments with half-baked ideas....


To save on rubber, MLB invents the balata ball. No home runs are hit in the first 11 games and the ball is shelved.


I can't pitch night games or my Mom will be upset....


On September 16, Carl Schweib (age 16) becomes the youngest pitcher in a ML game.


More is not always better....


The Phillies play 43 doubleheaders. The White Sox play 44.


*1944*


As if puberty weren't complicated enough....


15 year-old Joe Nuxhall of the Reds becomes the youngest pitcher to appear in a 20th century game on June 10.


There is no I in Tom Sunkel....


Tom Sunkel is the last one-eyed player to play in MLB.


How I learned to love World War II....


Tigers' rookie Chuck Hostetler hits .298 in 90 games. He is 41 at the time.


Miguel Batista would have one out in the second inning at this point....


The Braves' Red Barrett tosses a 58 pitch complete game on August 10 against the Reds.


So I got a little sidetracked, sue me....


The Browns clinch the AL flag with a starting pitcher (Sig Jakucki) who hasn't played in the majors since 1936.


Gotta be steroids....


The Washington Senators hit 23 home runs. Stan Spence accounts for 18.


Now that's a 1-2 punch....


Tiger pitchers Hal Newhouser (29-9, 2.22 ERA) and Spinning Salmon, er, Dizzy Trout (27-14, 2.12 ERA) finish 1-2 in MVP voting.


*1945*


The doctor wondered how he got a concussion from adjusting his cup....


One-armed outfielder Pete Gray plays a full season with the St. Louis Browns--he hits .218.


I think Miguel Batista's second leg is holding him back....


Bert Shepard of the Washington Senators surrenders three hits, a walk, and a single run in a 5.1 IP relief appearance--with one leg.


And you want us to fill the cup why?....


The Senators hit one HR in Griffith Stadium--an inside-the-parker.


Gerkin's pickle....


Steve Gerkin of the Athletics has a 3.62 ERA in 102 IP, and goes 0-12. He never pitches in MLB again.


Where have you gone Vince DiMaggio pitchers turn their lonely eyes to you....


The Phillies Vince DiMaggio leads the NL in whiffs for the fourth straight year He K's 387 times from 1942-45.


Baby Boomer....


Dodgers shortstop Tommy Brown becomes the youngest MLer to hit a home run (17) on August 20.


*1946*


It's amazing what a few years rest will do....


In his first full season since 1941 Bob Feller goes 26-15, 2.18 ERA in 371.1 IP fanning 348. He also tosses 36 complete games.


Which is 200 more than he fanned in the big leagues....


Bill Kennedy of Rocky Mount in the Coastal Plains League goes 28-3, 1.03 ERA with 456 punch-outs.


Which is why God gave us two butt cheeks....


Mel Ott gets the boot from both games of a doubleheader.


*1947*


It's the red socks, isn't it?....


Ted Williams hits .406 in 1941 and loses the MVP to Joe DiMaggio. In 1942 he wins the Triple Crown and loses the MVP to the Yankees' Joe Gordon. Now Williams once again cops the Triple Crown and loses the MVP to Joe DiMaggio by one vote.


Did they bring in the closer?....


The Reds Ewell Blackwell throws a no-hitter on June 18. He then throws eight no-hit innings in his next start.


*1948*


Going out with a bang-bang-bang-bang....


Pat Seerey of the White Sox hits 4 HR in an 11 inning game on July 18. He has four AB in 1949 and is then out of baseball for good.


Geriantics....


Satchel Paige, somewhere between age 42-48 makes his major league debut with the Cleveland Indians. He goes 6-1, 2.48 ERA and helps the Tribe to the World Series.


Again?....


Stan Musial has four five-hit games.


*1949*


Consolation prize....


Ted Williams misses the Triple Crown by less than .001 in BA to George Kell but wins the MVP.


It could've been higher had Toronto been in the league....


The Philadelphia A's turn 217 double plays.


The tarp must have eaten them....


The St. Louis Cardinals steal 17 bases as a team.


In Soviet Russia beaver shoots you!....


A deranged female fan shoots and almost kills Eddie Waitkus in a hotel room.


One man gang....


On July 6, Walker Cooper of the Reds goes 6-for-7 and rips three HR.


Isn't this how bullpens are used today?....


In the final game of the season, the St. Louis Browns use a pitcher an inning, for all nine innings.


Today's link is Netshrine....A Celebration of Baseball. It's got a little bit of everything from opinions to history and the forums are top notch. Very addictive.


Best Regards


John

Wednesday, May 05, 2004

This time--1920-39:


*1920*


I guess this is why they invented KY jelly....


The spitball is officially banned from baseball. Some say the impetus behind this ruling was the fatal beaning of the Indians Ray Chapman by Carl Mays. Chapman habitually hung over the plate so much that Mays claimed had the pitch not hit Chapman it would've been called a strike.


There are no Eighth Commandments in baseball....


Cleveland's Larry Gardner attempted 23 base thefts; he succeeded three times.


If a tie is like kissing your sister, I'm guessing you'd have to go Arkansas for this....


On May 1, Brooklyn's Leon Cadore and Joe Oeschger of the Boston Braves pitch all 26 innings of a 1-1 tie.


I'll bet the guy who started game three was told to pitch a complete game....


On October 2, the Pirates and Reds play the final tripleheader in MLB history.


John Kruk would be so proud....


The Philadelphia Phillies draw just 283 walks--an all-time record.


Designate THIS....


Former pitchers Babe Ruth and George Sisler set significant batting marks. Ruth slugs an all-time record .847 and Sisler bats .407.


Landis in Wonderland after chasing a white Rabbit Maranville....


Lost in the glare of the Black Sox scandal was that former Federal League batting champ Benny Kauff is thrown out of baseball for life by commissioner (and former judge) Kenesaw Mountain Landis. His crime? Being found not guilty in court for being a part of a stolen car ring. Landis felt, despite the court's ruling, that he was probably guilty anyway.


I wonder who Mom was rooting for?....


In the 1920 Fall Classic between Brooklyn and Cleveland, Jimmy Johnson (Brooklyn) and brother Doc (Cleveland) faced off. Doc hit .273 and Jimmy batted .214; neither garnered an extra base hit or an RBI.


*1921*


Now if we could only get the umpires to wear them....


St. Louis Cardinal "Specs" Toporcer becomes the first major league player to wear glasses on the field. Any guesses what bench jockeys around the NL called him?


Lucky seven....for the rest of the NL....


Reds' catcher Ivy Wingo leads the league in errors for the seventh straight year.


Usually you go to the cellar to avoid things that suck so bad they register on the Fujita Scale....


For the seventh straight year the Philadelphia Athletics finish dead last.


Don't look at me boys....


Waite Hoyt of the Yankees starts three games in the World Series, posts an ERA of 0.00 but loses the final game of the Fall Classic 1-0 against the Giants.


*1922*


Memo to Mr. Mack--walk him....


Detroit Tigers Harry Heilmann hits 21 HR. Ten of them are hit at Shibe Park against the Athletics.


Kind of makes you wonder why they bothered to go to the bullpen....


In late August, the Cubs beat the Phillies 26-23.


Jurisimprudence....

The Supreme Court rules that baseball is not a business and not subject to antitrust laws.


Why they didn't nickname him "Moose"....


Rabbit Maranville has 672 at bats and 0 home runs.


*1923*


Maybe if Rey Ordonez started in 1923....


Babe Ruth reaches base 379 times in 1923.


Did you know Miguel Batista pitched in 1923 for the Red Sox?....


On July 17, the Cleveland Indians score 13 runs against the BoSox in the sixth inning--all with two outs.


Urine sample size?....


New York Giants hurler Jack Bentley hits .406 while Cleveland Indians pitcher George Uhle sets a major league record by banging out 52 hits.


Why my great-grandchildren routinely take a leak on your grave....


Howard Ehmke of the Red Sox no-hits the A's on September 7. In his next start Ehmke tosses a one-hitter, the official scorer calls a potential error the only hit of the game.


Stranding 325....


Paul Strand of the PCL's Salt Lake City club notches 325 hits in 1923. Paul Schneider of the Vernon club rips five HR and a double in a single game.


*1924*


Mary had a little....er, make it a double....


Lyman Lamb of Tulsa in the Western League reaches the century mark in doubles 100.


Just dial 1-800-HR-BALCO....


World champion Washington Senators hit 22 HR as a team.


A clogged toilet runs better....


The Cubs are caught stealing an NL record 149 times.


Of course a guy nicknamed Stuffy wouldn't whiff much....


Stuffy McInnis sets an NL record for fewest strikeouts by a 1B (six).


*1925*


John Kruk would never approve....


Cleveland Indians Joe Sewell whiffs four times in 608 AB. In 7132 career AB Sewell K's just 114 times.


If chicks dig the longball then this is a vow of celibacy....


The Washington Senators' Sam Rice hits an AL record 182 singles.


And you thought he was just another pretty pitcher....


Walter Johnson (in 97 AB) bats .433 and posts an OPS of 1.032.


He did O.K. in the majors too....


Tony Lazzeri hits 60 HR for Salt Lake City in the PCL.


Maybe if he made more productive outs....


On July 3, Brooklyn Dodgers Milt Stock has his fourth straight four hit game. He hit .328 that year and was out of MLB the following year.


I'm guessing the Blue Jay bullpen invented a time machine....


On June 15, the Indians are up 15-4 over the A's in the 8th inning. The A's rally to win 17-15.


Would a salary cap and revenue sharing help at all?....


The International League's Baltimore Orioles cop their seventh straight IL pennant.


Hero to zero....


Washington Senator Roger Peckinpaugh wins the AL MVP award then commits eight errors in the World Series.


*1926*


But he never got past first base until he turned 19....


A Giants 17 year-old rookie outfielder becomes the youngest NLer to get a pinch hit. His name? Mel Ott.


Charles Comiskey no doubt regrets he didn't pay by the hour....


White Sox hurler Ted Lyons no-hits the Red Sox in 1:07.


Reading the Hysterical Abstract....


Reading of the International League posts a .194 winning percentage (31-129). Fan Appreciation Day canceled when he didn't show up.


That sobbing you hear is from the concessionaires....


On September 26 the Yankees and Browns complete a doubleheader in 2:07.


*1927*


Oddly enough....


For the fourth odd year in succession, Harry Heilmann wins the AL batting crown (.398).


Thanks for nothing....


On May 17, Boston Braves' Bob Smith pitches a 22 inning CG losing 4-3 to the Cubs.


Eating Brownies....


The Yankees send the Browns packing 21 times in 1927.


John Kruk would never approve II....


The Philadelphia A's fan an AL record low 326 times.


Why you don't want to hit after the pitcher....


Lloyd Waner scores 133 runs but notches just 27 RBI.


How the manager lets the bullpen know he's lost all confidence in them....


35 year old Jack Scott (9-21, 5.10 ERA) becomes the oldest pitcher to hurl two CG in the same day.


*1928*


It's true! There's no such thing as a clutch hitter!....


Washington Senators' Milt Gaston pitches a 14-hit shutout against Cleveland on July 10.


Gigantic futility....


The New York Giants win 25 games in September and almost overtake the St. Louis Cardinals for the pennant.


Ruth and Gehrig enjoy a little Bondage....


Babe Ruth hits .625 in the World Series and Lou Gehrig bats .545 with a 1.727 SLG. They combine for 7 HR and 13 RBI.


*1929*


The defense not only rests, it's dead....


Poor fielding Ike Boone of the PCL's Mission Reds collects 553 total bases. He'd hit .370 over his minor league career and .321 (1159 AB) in the majors. He couldn't stick due to poor defense.


Perhaps a designated pitcher rule would help....


The Phillies have four players who notch 200 hits: Lefty O Doul (254), Fresco Thompson (202), Pinky Whitney (200), and Chuck Klein (219); they finish 71-82 as the pitching staff posts a 6.13 ERA--Russ Miller goes 0-12.


Did you expect him to beat himself?....


The White Sox Art Shires, who worked as a prizefighter in the offseason beats up manager Lena Blackburne three times.


Under threat of death....


Ivy Wingo retires with the most career errors by a catcher (234).


*1930*


Once a catcher, always a catcher....


On January 10, White Sox/Senator Art Shires K.O's knocks out Braves' catcher Al Spohrer at Boston Garden. Shires was obviously the better hitter. Shires hit .291 lifetime, Spohrer: .259.


It's the Baker Bowl silly....


The Phillies Chuck Klein sets NL 20th century records for runs (158), total bases (445), and runs produced (288). He also registers 44 outfield assists.


When pitching hell wasn't located in Colorado....


The Phillies' pitching staff has a team ERA of 6.71. Leo Sweetland goes 7-15, 7.71 ERA; Claude Willoughby posts a 4-17, 7.59 ERA; Hap Collard's mark is 6-12, 6.80 ERA; and Hal Elliot's ledger reads 6-11, 7.69 ERA. Opposing teams bat .342 off Phils' pitching and score 1199 runs.


Sit the bum down....


Babe Ruth becomes the first documented player to whiff 1000 times in his career.


From the "Aaaah, he won't do it again" department....


On May 6, Gene Rye, playing for Waco in the Texas League hits three homers in the same inning.


But he was only 22 years old in the Dominican Republic....


Jack Quinn of the Philadelphia A's becomes the oldest player to hit a major league home run (46). He'd lead the NL in saves (15) the following season with Brooklyn.


But he tested positive for prune juice....


Sam Rice of the Washington Senators registers 207 hits, 121 runs, and 271 total bases--at age 40.


Getting a little bush....


Cubbie hurler Guy Bush surrenders 155 earned runs.


Check the birth certificate dumbass....


St. Louis Cardinal rookie George Watkins hits .373, posts an OPS of 1.037. In 1932 he hits .312, his only other .300 season. He plays his final major league season in 1936.


Next time strike out and keep the inning going....


On July 25, the Cleveland Indians hit into two triple plays against the A's.


*1931*


Designed to specs....


The Cardinals' Chick Hafey wins the batting crown (.349), he's the first player with glasses to accomplish the feat.


Some splinters aren't splendid, just ask the scrubs....


Wes Ferrell of the Indians is 22-12, 3.75 ERA, rips nine home runs and has an OPS of .994 in 116 at bats. He also threw a no-hitter on April 29.


Double take....


Earl Webb of the Red Sox hits a MLB record 67 doubles.


I bet the umpires just loved reminding managers of this....


Balls hit over the fence on the bounce are now ruled doubles--not home runs.


Well, they were DIPS....


On July 17, the White Sox beat the Browns 10-8 in 12 innings. No pitcher whiffed a hitter the entire game.


Tricycle....


Babe Herman of the Brooklyn Dodgers hits for the cycle three times.


He couldn't even catch a buzz....


Buzz Arlett plays in his sole major league season. The giant (6' 4" 230 lb.) Buzz Arlett in his sole major league season with the Phillies finished fifth in slugging, fifth in OPS and fourth in home runs with 18. However early in his career a Cardinals' scout stuck the "good hit, no field" label on him and it haunted him the rest of his career. However his minor league career was eerily reminiscent of another pitcher turned slugger -- Babe Ruth. Arlett started his career as a right-handed spitball pitcher -- with the reputation of "he's a good hitter, for pitcher" -- with the hometown Oakland Oaks in 1918 and went on to win 108 games, twice going over 25 wins in a season. The Detroit Tigers looked at him, but without the spitball, which he wouldn't be able to use in the majors, they did not consider him a prospect.


However arm miseries set in early in 1923 and Arlett switched to the outfield, however, once becoming a regular outfielder turned into a monster hitter, averaging nearly .360 with 30 homers and 140 RBIs through the rest of the 1920s, however the label put on him by the Cardinal scout kept him in the minors until the Phillies took a chance on him in 1931 (the season when the National League introduced a "dead ball" in reaction to the hitting orgies of 1929-1930). Like his teammate Chuck Klein, he found hitting in the 'Baker Bowl' to be a tremendously rewarding experience. Regardless, at the end of the year Arlett was sent to Baltimore, where in 1932 he hit 4 homers in a game twice within a five-week period and led the league with 54 homers for the season, but he would never return to the majors.


*1932*


This would buy you 54 games from Kevin Cash today....


Connie Mack sells HOFer Al Simmons, Jimmy Dykes, and Mule Haas to the White Sox for $100,000.


Pinch me, I'm dreaming....


Brooklyn Dodger Johnny Frederick hits six pinch hit home runs.


Another chapter from the "Cito Gaston--Confidence For Dummies" book....


On July 10, A's hurler Ed Rommel coughs up 29 hits and 14 runs in a relief appearance.


It's a pity he couldn't go to arbitration....


Wes Ferrell posts his fourth straight 20-win campaign in his fourth full major league season. He is 91-48, 3.57 ERA over those years.


There's no place like home....there's no place like home....there's no place like home....


The Yankees go 62-15 at Yankee Stadium.


That scream you heard was John Kruk waking up from this nightmare....


The Yanks' Joe Sewell whiffs just three times in 503 AB.


Was he as annoying as Tim McCarver and John Cerutti?....


Former Indians OF Jack Graney (.250 18 HR 420 RBI lifetime) becomes the first former player to be hired as a play-by-play announcer (by Cleveland).


Mission: Control....


Alvin Crowder (26-13, 3.33 ERA) of the Washington Senators pitches 327 innings and doesn't throw a wild pitch or hit a batter. He walked just 77 hitters.


*1933*


And I bet they both got booed....


Philadelphia saw two players cop the triple crown. Philadelphia A's 1B Jimmy Foxx went .356 48 HR 163 RBI; and Philadelphia Phillies' OF Chuck Klein batted .368 28 HR 120 RBI.


Ever wonder what a Bud Selig wet dream looks like?....


Despite winning the triple crown, A's owner forced Jimmy Foxx to take a pay cut because his HR totals dropped from 58 to 48.


Waiting for Lefty....


Lefty Grove shuts out the Yankees on August 3, the first time in 309 games that the Bronx Bombers were held scoreless.


And you can't blame the DH....


The NL (3.34) posts an ERA nearly a full run lower than the AL (4.28).


There was rampant speculation that BALCO was supplying him with Geritol....


Nick Altrock pinch hits for the Washington Senators--he was 57 at the time.


If only he could pitch....


On April 25, Yankee rookie pitcher Russ Van Atta sets a MLB record for hits by a pitcher in his first start (four). He was 33-41, 5.59 ERA for his career.


Blame the pitching staff....


Phillies infielder Mickey Finn dies from an ulcer.


This will get you 120 games from Kevin Cash today....


The A's sell/trade Mickey Cochrane, Lefty Grove, Rube Walberg, and Max Bishop to the Tigers and Red Sox for $225,000.


*1934*


Sealed with a Clip....


The New York Yankees purchase an OF from the San Francisco Seals for $25,000. His name? Joe DiMaggio.


They must have been awfully ugly grandchildren....


Senators' owner Clark Griffith sells his son-in-law Joe Cronin to the Red Sox for $250,000 and Lyn Lary.


Junior achievement....


Tribe rookie Hal Trosky collects 374 total bases.


Your [pink] slip is showing....


The Yankees release Herb Pennock and Joe Sewell on the same day--both will eventually be enshrined in the Hall of Fame.


Spit happens one last time....


Burleigh Grimes wins the last game ever by a pitcher who could throw a legal spitball on May 1.


Jack Russell terror....


Jack Russell (5-10, 4.16 ERA; 7 saves) of the Senators becomes the first reliever selected as an all star (he was 12-6, 2.69 ERA; 13 saves the previous year).


Did they stop the game to commemorate the feat?....


Firpo Marberry becomes first reliever to notch 100 saves.


And he did it on merit....


Milt Gaston retires with a 97-164, 4.55 ERA ledger. He posted winning seasons in his first two seasons and none thereafter. Gaston was 23-71 over his final four ML campaigns.


Ed Sprague played his entire career trying to duplicate the feat thinking it was his ticket to the Hall-of-Fame....


Tigers' OF and future HOFer Goose Goslin bangs into four double plays.


*1935*


How to take all the fun out of a double switch....


Wes Ferrell (25-14, 3.52 ERA) bangs out 52 hits. He rips seven HR and posts an OPS of .960.


How bad were the Braves? Even Babe Ruth couldn't help....


Babe Ruth is released from the Yankees and inks a three-year contract with the Braves. On May 25 he slugs three HR at Forbes Field and retires shortly thereafter. Ruth's lifetime OPS is 1.164. The Braves finish the year 38-115.


The perfect guest....


The Braves are 13-65 on the road.


Hey, didn't you used to be Ben Cantwell?....


Cantwell of the Braves who was 20-10, 2.61 ERA in 1933 tumbled to 4-25, 4.61 ERA.


I'm surrounded by idiots....


Wally Berger of the Braves leads the NL in HR (34) and RBI (130).


Not much point in keeping you too--is there?....


The A's sell Jimmy Foxx and Johnny Marcum to the Red Sox for $150,000.


Turn on the lights this party's starting....


On May 24, the first night time games is played. The Reds beat the Phillies at Crosley Field.


*1936*


Das boot....


The Phillies commit 252 errors.


However he never relieved himself on the mound....


Dizzy Dean is the last ML pitcher to lead the loop in wins (28) and saves (11).


Tom Yawkey grabs Connie's boob....


The A's trade Boob McNair and Doc Cramer to the Red Sox for two minor leaguers and $75,000.


Professional courtesy....


Pirates' catcher Hal Finney goes 0-35, doesn't draw a single walk but scores three runs and drives in three.


*1937*


TINSTAAPP....


The Braves have two 30+ year-old rookie pitchers: Lou Fette (20-10, 2.88 ERA) and Jim Turner (20-11, 2.38 ERA).


You can't always get what you want....


The Braves have the best staff ERA in the majors (3.22), but the worst team batting average (.247).


*1938*


O.K. let's see you do it a third time....


Johnny Vander Meer throws no-hitters in consecutive starts on June 11 (Braves) and June 15 (Dodgers).


Pitch count hell....


Bob Feller leads MLB in strikeouts (240) and walks (208).


This achievement was positively seismic....


Hack Wilson leads the NL in stolen bases with 16.


The best support not found in a Victoria Secrets catalogue....


St. Louis Browns hurler Bobo Newsom wins 20 games (20-16) despite an ERA of 5.08.


What the Truck?....


Virgil Trucks (177-135, 3.38 ERA) fans 418 in the Alabama-Florida League while apprenticing in the minors.


He also never got to first base with Marilyn Monroe....


Vince DiMaggio sets a then-ML record by whiffing 134 times (since broken--repeatedly).


Have you got a better idea?....


On June 16, Jimmy Foxx was walked six times by the St. Louis Browns.


*1939*


Fourth of July fireworks....


Red Sox Jim Tabor hits two grandslams on Independence Day.


Planting couch potatoes....


Baseball is first televised on August 26 as the Reds visit the Dodgers at Ebbets Field.


And his manager needed a triple bypass....


On August 4, White Sox OF Mike Kreevich hits into four double plays.


Maybe he just took a sip of HGH....


Braves' OF Johnny Cooney plays from 1921-38 (1953 AB) without hitting a home run. He hit a home run both on September 24 and 25 and then never hit another in his career (2 HR/3372 AB).


But he knew how to win!....


Earl Whitehill retires with a 218-185, 4.36 ERA record. It's the highest ERA for a pitcher with 200+ wins.


Schmidt happens....


Northern Leaguer Bob Schmidt of Duluth bats an organized baseball record .441.


Come over for a visit and you can eat some Brownies....


The Browns finish with a home record of 18-59.


It's big, it's bad, and it's baseball. Big Bad Baseball is the haunt of the "baseball crank" Don Malcolm. Always edgy, always informative, always fun.


Best Regards


John

Monday, May 03, 2004

1900-1919


Two things I enjoy doing are: (1) watching the Montreal Expos and (2) watching the Toronto Blue Jays. Since I'm really trying to hold off on spewing invective and aren't quite sure if this blog has a profanity filter, I'll put off writing about them until things look a little brighter. So, two other things I enjoy doing are: (1) finding obscure or old feats in baseball and (2) jotting them down for future reference. It's amazing what you accumulate over time. So I thought I'd share my version of "Believe It Or Not." So, I've arranged them chronologically and will feature this again in future:


*1900*


And you thought Ed Sprague was bad....


New York Giants' third baseman "Piano Legs" Hickman committed 86 errors.


*1901*


Here's a double play combo that only the Mets could love....


The Phillies keystone combo -- Bill Hallman and Monte Cross -- hit .184 and .197 respectively.


How old is Armando Benitez really?....


In a four game series Detroit swept Milwaukee winning each game in their last at bat. In the first game of the series; Milwaukee lead in the ninth 13-4 and lost the game 14-13.


How old is Pedro Martinez really?....


Philadelphia's Chick Fraser hits 31 batters.


*1902*


You'd think they'd try an intentional walk....


Texas Leaguer Nig Clarke went 8-for-8 with eight home runs.


How old is Rey Ordonez really?....


Phillies 2B/SS Pete Childs slugs a mighty .206 over 403 AB. His career SLG was .231 and his career OPS was a awe-inspiring (in a bad way) .523.


*1903*


Manager Bill Armour must have thought the same way as Cito Gaston did, let 'em keep playing to show you haven't lost confidence in them....


Cleveland Naps SS John Gochnauer made 98 errors. Of course he must've been a heckuva hitter to stay in the lineup--right? Wrong. He hit a lusty .185.


Effectively wild?


On September 18, Chick Fraser no-hits the Cubs. At least no-hit their bats.


Why the Phillies sucked so bad for so long (or call him the original Dick Allen)....


Bill Keister led his team in HR and RBI while batting .320. Did he win team MVP? Not sure--they released him, you can say the Phillies gave their team a kick in the Keister.


Do you think Alan Trammell has actually thought of doing it?....


Detroit Tigers' manager Win Mercer commits suicide in the preseason.


*1904*


Couldn't they just spit on him like regular ballplayers?....


Giants players led by skipper John McGraw beat an umpire unconscious during spring training. Had that happened in this era the ump would likely be forced by Don Fehr to apologize to the players for bruising their knuckles thereby risking their careers.


He didn't play for the Yankees however....


Jim O'Rourke caught a game for the New York Giants--he was 52.


*1905-06*


There aren't your Daddy's Braves....


The Boston Braves had four 20-game losers in their rotation: Irv Young 20-21 Vic Willis 12-29 Chick Fraser 14-21 and Kaiser Wilhelm 3-23. Interestingly, all four pitchers surrendered 122 earned runs that year.


And just to prove it wasn't a fluke....


After that kind of abysmal season the best thing to do is revamp the pitching staff, right? Wrong. With three new starters the Braves still have a quartet of 20-game losers: Irv Young 16-25 Vive Lindaman 12-23 Jeff Pfeffer 13-22 and Gus Dorner 8-25.


And you thought Don Baylor was tough on pitchers....


The Cubs/Cardinals right-hander Jack Taylor tosses 118 consecutive complete games (streak ended in 1906) and the PCL's Rube Vickers hurls an all time organized baseball record 526 innings.


*1907*


Why? He wasn't managing the Tigers....


Red Sox skipper Chick Stahl commits suicide during Spring Training.


This would be a funny salary arbitration hearing to listen in on....


Detroit won the pennant with a 92-58 ledger. Tigers right-hander George Mullin is a 20 game loser (20-20) that year.


*1908*


And you thought Don Baylor was tough on pitchers (part two)....


The Chicago Cubs Ed Reulbach tosses shutouts in both ends of a doubleheader. Walter Johnson tossed three shutouts over a four day stretch against the New York Highlanders (Yankees).


*1909*


In the "But you can't measure his contributions with raw statistics! He had great intangibles and could call one hell of a game and offered leadership in the clubhouse!" department....


In 1909, Brooklyn Dodgers catcher Bill Bergen catches 112 games--and hits a magnificent .139. Bergen had over 3000 ML at bats and hit .170. His career OBP was .194 and he slugged .201 giving him a jaw-dropping, eye-popping career OPS of .395! On August 23, 1909 Bergen goes 7-for-7 in throwing out base stealers.


This wouldn't happen if baseball had a salary cap....


Honus Wagner made the most money of his career in 1909--$10,000.


Then why did they call him "Home Run" Baker?....


The Philadelphia Athletics Frank Baker collects an AL rookie record 19 triples.


*1910*


This is what happens when you clone Rey Ordonez and Brian Hunter....


White Sox Hall-of-Famer Ed Walsh led the AL in ERA (1.26) and lost 20 games (18-20). The White Sox that year slugged a lusty .261.


What makes Scott Boras wake up in a cold sweat screaming....


Player salaries at this point in time range from $900-$12,000.


But did they call him "The Chairman of the [Emery] Board"?....


Canadian Yankee (O.K. Highlander) Russ Ford who popularized the "emery ball" sets an AL rookie record with 26 wins and eight shutouts. After a two-year stint in the Federal League Ford retired as he no longer could throw his best scuff.


Do you think [manager] Jack O Connor and [3B] Roy Hartzwell weren't on Ty Cobb's Christmas card list?....


Nap Lajoie wins the AL batting title over Cobb by going 8-for-8 on the final game of season. Seven of Lajoie's hits were bunt singles up the third base line.


Good thing he didn't go 5-for-5 or they might have had him shot....


On September 30, 21-year old Ray Jansen of the St. Louis Browns makes his major league debut and goes 4-for-5 (all singles). He never plays another game in the major leagues.


*1911*


The blind leading the blind....


1911 is the first year that baseball employs more than one umpire on the field.


Well, at least it gives Miguel Batista and Josh Towers something to shoot for....


On May 13, the New York Giants score 10 runs in the first inning against the St. Louis Cardinals before the Cards get their first out.


*1912*


Mo Vaughn matched this in an afternoon at Wendy's...


Pittsburgh Pirates outfielder Chief Wilson legs out 36 triples. His next highest season total was 14 which he accomplished the following year. "Shoeless Joe" Jackson sets the AL mark that year with 26.


*1913*


But did they have to burp him afterward?....


Mel Acosta, a 17-year old rookie with the Washington Senators becomes the youngest player to get a pinch hit in AL history.


*1914*


You can never have too much pitching....


On July 1, The Boston Red Sox debuts a rookie southpaw who pitches seven innings to beat the Cleveland Naps. His name?--Babe Ruth.


Obeying the Eighth Commandment....


Cardinals SS (and future Hall-of-Fame manager for the Yankees) Miller Huggins is caught stealing 36 times (in 68 attempts).


*1915*


Isn't it ironic?....


On May 5, Red Sox southpaw hurler Babe Ruth hits his first career HR off of Jack Warhop--of the New York Yankees.


Well, at least it wasn't for Ernie Broglio....


The Cleveland Indians get Braggo Roth and cash from the Chicago White Sox--for OF Joe Jackson.


You can never have too much pitching II....


St. Louis Browns feature a rookie southpaw who beats the immortal Walter Johnson in his major league debut--George Sisler.


And his grandchildren still don't believe him....


On April 24, the Red Sox decided to pinch hit Hack Cady for the pitcher. It was the last time Babe Ruth was pinch hit for.


Something for Rick Ankiel and Mark Wohlers to shoot for....


The Philadelphia A's give the ball to rookie southpaw Bruno Haas. Haas walks 16 as the A's lose (not surprisingly) 15-7.


Remember me?....


Bill Hinchman returns to the majors with Pittsburgh after spending 1910-14 in the minors (he played for Cleveland in 1909). He'll lead the NL in triples the following year.


*1916*


The name game....


Former major league utility infielder John "I guess I didn't" Dodge is killed by a pitch thrown by "Shotgun" Rogers in a Southern Association game.


I guess the fans in the outfield bleachers never got the memo....


Chicago Cubs owner Charles Weegham is the first team owner who allows fans to keep balls hit out of play.


April games do count....


The New York Giants finish fourth in the NL with a 86-66 despite having a 26-game winning streak.


*1917*


Oh no, No-no-No-no....


On May 2, Cincinnati Reds right hander Fred Toney (24-16, 2.20 ERA), and Chicago Cubs southpaw Hippo Vaughn (23-13, 2.01 ERA) throw mutual no-hitters through nine innings. Toney will win it in ten [innings]: 1-0.


Ernie row your Babe a-Shore....


On June 23, Babe Ruth walks the first batter of a game against the Senators, argues the [ball four] call and is ejected. Ernie Shore comes into the game, picks the runner off first, and retires the next 26 hitters to face him.


Win one for the Gipper....


The Pittsburgh Pirates hire Hugo Bedzek as their manager. His previous job? A college football coach.


*1918*


Our pitcher who Art in trouble, hollowed be our bats....


On August 1, Boston Braves southpaw (184-120, 3.20 ERA lifetime) Art Nehf throws 20 shutout innings. The Braves (and Nehf) lose 2-0 in the 21st.


Of course they didn't have commercials--or TV for that matter....


On August 31, the New York Giants beat the Brooklyn Dodgers 1-0. The game lasted just 57 minutes.


*1919*


"They stole them on the pitcher--honest"....


On July 7, Giants catcher Mike Gonzalez allows eight stolen bases in a single inning.


This will hoit. This Joe didn't even get a song by Simon and Garfunkel and he never bagged Marilyn Monroe....


Western Leaguer Joe Wilhoit of Wichita registers hits in a record 69 consecutive games.


Would you like that hot dog to go?....


On September 28, the Giants beat the Phillies 6-1 in a record 51 minutes.


We've got the beat today, or more pointedly Rich's Weekend Baseball BEAT. Like me Rich is a baseball history buff. (or did he say he reads about baseball history in the buff?) Regardless of his sartorial habits (or lack thereof) it's a fun site and feel free to drop a comment or several on his musings. Personally, I like the fact that he mixes sabermetrics with his history; what do I mean? Well, you'll just have to surf over and find out for yourself.


Best Regards


John




Saturday, April 24, 2004

With all the emphasis on “Moneyball” the last [long] while I thought it’d be fun to construct an all-time “Moneyball” team. I’m going to put together a lineup that would be far better than the sum of its parts. Nowadays, most teams carry about twelve pitchers. So I've picked thirteen others to man every position on the diamond including the DH and some bench players. The difference between the starters and the scrubs is mainly defense, although there are a couple of players who had other things to offer with the bat that would help offset any defensive shortcomings. For the most part, however, this group wouldn't boot away too many ballgames. Since the main thrust of this new philosophy is the value of on-base percentage, we’ll put together this roster with that as the main criteria. The four stats you see listed along with the player are batting average, on base percentage, career walks, and Runs Created Above Average (RCAA).


Leadoff: 2B--Max Bishop (.271/.423/1153/53 RCAA)


Max Bishop was the lead-off hitter and second baseman for Connie Mack's Philadelphia Athletics three time American League pennant and back-to-back World Champions (1929-1930--lost the WS in '31). Bishop was a poor man's version of the Yankees' Earle Combs, in that he set the table for sluggers Jimmy Foxx, Al Simmons, and Mickey Cochrane much the same way as Combs did for Babe Ruth, Lou Gehrig, and Tony Lazzeri. With the 1929 world champs, he batted .232 for the season yet posted an OBP of .398 due to leading the league in walks. Over twelve big league seasons he drew 1153 walks and posted a career on base mark of .423 despite a batting mark of .271 lifetime. Bishop had some extra base power too, as evidenced by banging out 236 doubles, 35 triples, and 41 home runs over the span of his career (albeit in a big hitting era). He has the dubious distinction of being the last out in the history of the Philadelphia Athletics' World Series play, when he flied out to St. Louis Cardinal centerfielder Pepper Martin in Game Seven of the 1931 World Series. Nicknamed, "Camera Eye," he lived up to that moniker superbly.


#2: 3B--Tony Phillips (.266/.374/1319/160 RCAA)


Phillips was a player whose game aged like a fine wine (as evidenced by his leading the AL in free passes in both 1993 and 1996). For example, from 1982-1990 he was a below average player (.251/.343/.350 -9 RCAA). Then at age 32 a light went on and he went on a five year tear (.282/.402/.422 154 RCAA) and continued on as a useful spare part (.259/.378/.401 15 RCAA) until his retirement in 1999. Although Tony Phillips lacked the speed of a young Rickey Henderson or a Tim Raines, he was an accomplished lead-off hitter and savvy baserunner. From 1990, he didn't post an on base mark below .362, and as he got older he developed more power. From 1982-1990 he hit 41 home runs; after that, he launched 131 (with a career high 27 in 139 games in the strike shortened 1995 season). Four times he topped 100 runs. Although not a Gold Glove calibre defensive player, he hardly embarrassed himself either. He was capable both in the infield as well as the outfield, including CF. A durable player, he played in 1326 games starting in 1989, despite not having a fixed position. A favorite of Tony LaRussa because of his versatility, he was a vital cog in the Oakland A's World Championship team of 1989.


#3: RF--Jimmy Wynn (.250/.369/1224/320 RCAA)


Like Bob Allison, Gene Tenace, and Mickey Tettleton (whom will be dealt with shortly), "the Toy Cannon" was that valuable mix of power and selectivity and certainly belongs on this roster. Among his achievements are eight 20+ home run seasons with three over 30. He walloped 285 career doubles and went yard 291 times. Wynn had a fabulous 10 year peak from 1965-74 where he was 300 Runs Created Above Average despite batting just .259. Despite playing the bulk of his games in tough hitter’s parks and in a low offensive era he averaged 25 HR and 90 BB during that span--not too shabby for a guy who was just a tad smaller than Pee Wee Reese. It's all the more impressive when you consider that he was a contemporary of Sandy Koufax, Don Drysdale, Juan Marichal, Bob Gibson, Warren Spahn etc. He also spent a couple of campaigns in another venue (Dodger Stadium) noted for leeching power hitters' numbers and slammed 40 HR in 947 AB toward the end of his career.


Other tidbits:


Wynn lead the National League in walks twice: 1969 and 1976. Wynn was among the top six in walks drawn in the National League every year from 1968-76. Although Wynn never hit .300 in any season, he twice posted an OBP over .400 (1969 and 1975). In 1968 and 1969, Wynn finished sixth in National League OPS. Both years he hit just .269. Despite playing half of his games in pitchers' parks, Wynn finished among the top ten in NL home runs five times over eight years (1967-74). He was in the top six in all but one of those seasons (he finished 10th in 1972). In 1969, and 1975-76 Wynn finished the season with more walks than hits. In his 30 game stint with the 1977 Yankees, Wynn walked (15) more often than he hit (11).


#4: CF--Bob Allison (.255/.360/795/194 RCAA)


Allison won the 1959 American League Rookie of the Year with the Washington Senators. He blasted 30 circuit clouts, a very impressive total in old Griffith Stadium for a right handed hitter. Why? The dimensions (in Allison's time) were 421 ft to center, 380 ft to left center, and 350 ft to left. Griffith Stadium was considered to be a very pitcher friendly park. Hall-of-Fame hurler Hal Newhouser once quipped: "Give a pitcher a ball-hawk in centerfield and he will win in Washington." Due to Griffith Stadium, Washington never produced an American League Home Run King until Roy Sievers turned the trick in 1957 (with 42).


Metropolitan Stadium was a little kinder to his swing and he continued to post impressive numbers. Like Jimmy Wynn, he was forced to spend his prime years during the pitching-friendly 1960's (1963-68). During that six year span he posted a fine OPS of .847 (164 RCAA) and finished top in that category in 1963 with the phone number of the Blue Jays dugout: .911. In the full seasons he played those years (he batted only 168 times in 1966) he averaged close to 28 HR per year -- not Killibrew-esque to be sure, but -- a fine total nonetheless.


Career highlights include topping 20 home runs eight times and 30 thrice. Of his 1281 career hits, 525 went for extra bases. Possessor of a keen batting eye for a slugger, he would post an on base mark .100 points higher than his batting average regularly. Strangely, his three worst seasons coincided with one pennant winner (1965 as the transplanted Twins) and two divisional champions (in 1969 and 1970, again with Minnesota--although he was clearly on the downside of his career, they were his last two seasons). He had back to back 100 RBI seasons in 1960, and 1961.


#5: 1B/DH/#3 catcher--Mickey Tettleton (.241/.369/949/167 RCAA)


"Fruit Loops" was usually was among the top in the [American League] loop of walks drawn and on base percentage. Although his best defensive position is designated hitter, he could also fill in at first, catcher and the outfield corners if needed. He had a selective batting eye and a booming bat. He had hit 212 round trippers from 1989 to his retirement 44 AB into the 1997 season. Like Phillips, it took awhile for Tettleton to put it together. He didn’t get over 300 AB until he was 28. Once he was given regular at bats, he flourished posting an RCAA of 179 hitting 185 HR and walking 715 times from 1989 to 1995. You could usually count on Tettleton for 30 homers, 100 walks and 100 whiffs. Pitchers who faced him could usually count on a long ordeal, he was well known as a player who worked pitchers deep into counts looking for a pitch he could drive. The proud(?) possessor of a batting stance that ranked with Bobby Richardson and Tony Batista's in X-Files bizarre-ness he nonetheless flourished under Sparky Anderson while with the Tigers, and even led the Junior Circuit in walks in 1992 while stationed in MoTown (122).


#6: DH/supersub--Brian Downing (.267/.373/1197/289 RCAA)


One could forgive Brian Downing if he were to take a trip into the countryside, go deep into the woods, and when he was absolutely certain that no one was around--scream hysterically at the injustice of it all. He was present at the three of the four greatest triumphs of the Los Angeles/California/Anaheim Angels baseball franchise (division titles in 1979, 1982, and 1986). So, of course, he was also part of the two greatest disappointments in franchise history (1982 vs Milwaukee , when they lost the ALCS. 3-2 after leading 2-0, and 1986 vs Boston when they lost the ALCS. 4-3 after leading 3-1 ).


Yet in this period, he remained a superior offensive force as well as a serviceable multi-positional player as well, being a fixture in west coast baseball over three different decades (he played with the Halos from 1978-1990). Although his post season ledger is nothing to write home about (.197/.292/.262 average in three ALCS's, although in the 1986 series he did drive in seven runs) he had several standout seasons in AL play. He had six seasons of 20+ longballs as well as eleven consecutive campaigns of 10+ HR (1982-1992). All totalled: he banged out 360 doubles, blasted 275 HR, garnered 2099 hits, scored 1188 runs and drove home 1073 over 20 big league tours of duty. As befits this roster, he was also a selective hitter, walking (1197 times with a league topping 106 in 1987) as often as he whiffed (1127). He finished his career as a DH posting a .270/.378/.449 (140 RCAA) in that role over his final six seasons.


#7: LF--Roy Cullenbine (.276/.408/853/234 RCAA)


When you think of the 1945 Detroit World Series champions, what names come to mind? How about: Hank Greenberg, Hal Newhouser, or Rudy York? Perhaps Virgil Trucks or Dizzy Trout? How aboooooout--Roy Cullenbine? Who's Roy Cullenbine? If you happen to know who he is, then you may object: "What about him? He only hit .227 in the 1945 Fall Classic." Well yes, he did hit .227, but hey, Rudy York didn't even break the "Mendoza Line." But, getting back to the aforementioned Mr. Cullenbine, he did much more than just hit two-and-a-quarter (plus two pennies, keep the change). How's this for starters? In 30 trips to the plate, he reached base 13 times (that's an OBP of .433). He scored five runs, and his five hits produced four RBI. That's nine runs produced in a seven game series. That is a top quality World Series performance by anybody's reckoning.


His regular season ledger reads like a CAA/AAA road map. Over a 10 year career he spent time with the Brooklyn Dodgers, St. Louis Browns, Detroit Tigers (twice), Washington Senators, New York Yankees and the Cleveland Indians. A baseball enigma, he played his best baseball toward the end of his career. In his final season, he hit 18 doubles and blasted 24 home runs, of his 104 hits, 43 went for extra bases. He also scored 82 runs and drove in 78. He also drew 137 walks (and struck out only 51 times), turning an apparently anaemic .224 batting average (before you turn your nose up at this figure remember the 1945 World Series) into an eye popping OBP of .401. For those that might brand him a wartime wonder (.272/.401/.444/174 RCAA from 1941-45) in his final three seasons (1945-47) he hit 57 of his 110 HR, and was .271/.420/.459 with 111 RCAA before retiring. Also among his achievements is 209 doubles, drawing two walks for every whiff, and left the game with an on base mark of .408, despite hitting .276.


#8: SS--Eddie Stanky (.268/.410/996/122 RCAA)


A close call as to who'd get the nod for the start, “the brat,” or Donie Bush. Hall-of-Fame manager Leo Durocher put it best, when he said of Eddie Stanky: "He can't hit, he can't run, he can't field (he was about average defensively if you crunch the numbers), he can't throw. He can't do a damn but beat you." Stanky was a hard nosed, somewhat nasty ballplayer -- sort of a poor man's Ty Cobb -- who would go to any extent to help his team win. As a manager for the White Sox, he wasn't above a little skulduggery to give his team an edge. According to a Comiskey Park groundskeeper, Stanky would place balls into a humidifier twelve days before a homestand. He would then take them out hours before the game with the effect being that the outer surface of the ball would be dry, yet the balls would have gained a couple of ounces of moisture, thereby deadening them. The theory being, since the punchless Sox couldn't hit, then neither shall anybody else.


As for his playing career, he played on three National League Pennant winners for three different clubs: the 1947 Brooklyn Dodgers, the 1948 Boston Braves, and the 1951 New York Giants. Although not a power hitter, he knew how to create runs by being unbelievably picky at the plate drawing close to three walks for every strikeout. He garnered an on base mark .142 higher than his batting average and .062 higher than his slugging average (for the record he hit .268, slugged .348, and had an OBP of .410) In an eleven year career, he twice topped 100 runs, leading the league in 1945 and had five seasons of hitting twenty plus doubles while splitting time between second, third, and short. He finished at the top in walks three times (1945, 46, 50) and OBP twice (1946, 50). Stanky drew 685 walks in the six years from 1946-51, and had an RCAA of 113 despite a .368 SLG and hitting just 28 HR.


#9: Catcher--Wes Westrum (.217/.357/489/-16 RCAA)


A superb backstop for some excellent New York Giant teams; Wes Westrum handled some fine pitching staffs. Probably his best effort was the 1954 World Series when he played a big part in engineering the Giants stunning sweep of the heavily favored Cleveland Indians. Primarily a defensive backstop, he nonetheless would make opposing pitchers pay for any inattention on their part. He topped 20 circuit clouts and seventy ribbies in consecutive seasons (1950-51). Westrum also proved himself a top notch post season player as well. Besides his catching duties, he distinguished himself at the dish as well. In two World Series (1951 and 1954), he batted .250 drew six walks for an OBP of .371 and drove in five runs in ten games. He had an outstanding batting eye, despite hitting only .217 for his career he was so selective, he had a sparkling on base mark of .357. He finished his career with the same team he started with, playing all eleven seasons with the Giants. Although he was below average in comparison to other NL hitters, he was above average for a catcher and was 22 runs created better than an average NL catcher. He enjoyed a fairly respectable peak from 1949-52 hitting 64 HR with an RCAA of 31 despite batting .228 (.382 OBP).


The Bench:


INF UT--Donie Bush (.250/.356/1158/-90 RCAA)


Some guys just can't buy a break. In his first full season in the majors with the Detroit Tigers, Donie Bush found himself part of a pennant winning club only to lose the 1909 World Series to the Pittsburgh Pirates. No matter, it was the third straight pennant for the Tabbies plus they had Ty Cobb, Germany Schaefer and 'Wahoo Sam' Crawford still in their primes--right?


Wrong.


Detroit never went back to the Fall Classic during his playing days. To add insult to injury, he found himself in a Washington Senators uniform late in the 1921 season. He called it a career with the Senators in 1923. Washington then proceeded to win its first World Series title in 1924. Nonetheless, Bush was an offensive catalyst, getting on base, stealing, and scoring runs in bunches. Over a 16 year career he scored 1280 runs (great things happen when you hit ahead of Ty Cobb) topping 100 four times. He supplemented his .250 batting average by coaxing 1158 walks, posting a lifetime OBP of .356, as well as stealing 403 bases (I'd run a lot too if I had Mr. Cobb breathing down my back). Bush lead the AL in walks five times in six years (1909-1914). Bush makes the team because he was 106 runs created better than contemporary SS, but is relegated to the bench for being 90 runs created worse than average among AL hitters.


INF UT--Eddie Joost (.239/.361/1043/18 RCAA)


A versatile player, Eddie Joost could (and did) man all the infield positions. A (f)utility player defensively (read: the spiritual grandfather of Jose Offerman and Marv Throneberry) he kept himself in the lineup with a combination of patience and pop. In every season between 1947-1952, he tallied double digits in both doubles and homers with Connie Mack's Athletics. Seven times he posted 20+ doubles, and twice he topped twenty HR. He scored 100+ runs both in 1949 and 1951. His biggest offensive asset was his discerning batting eye. In six consecutive campaigns he drew 100+ walks, with a career high 149 in 1949 enabling him to post a lifetime on base mark of .361 despite batting an anaemic .239. Joost, like Tony Phillips, was a late bloomer. Joost opened his career (1936-47) with .221/.319/.307 and -88 RCAA. However, Joost had an RCAA of 106 with 96 HR despite hitting .257 from ages 32 through 36 while averaging 120 walks a season. He was a member of the 1940 World Champion Cincinnati Reds, playing shortstop and batting .200 in the seven game tournament.


1B/DH/backup catcher, pinch hitter--Gene Tenace (.241/.388/984/273 RCAA)


Gene Tenace used his unexpected 1972 World Series MVP as a springboard for a remarkable career. As a catcher, he threw like a Texas Rangers' starter, but made his bat his ticket to being a major league regular--putting in time at first, third, outfield, and designated hitter. Where he played, rings followed: from 1972-74 with the Oakland A's, and 1982 with the St. Louis Cardinals. Even as a bench coach, he attracted championships as Cito Gaston's first lieutenant (read: woke him up as the situation warranted) when the Toronto Blue Jays added two more rings to his collection in 1992 and 1993. As for his playing career he topped 20 home runs five times, drew 100+ free passes six times, and walked as often as he struck out (984 to 998) fashioning an OBP of .388 (despite only batting .241). Like many on this list, he appeared often among league leaders in bases on balls finishing in the top four every year from 1973-80 (save 1976) and landed on the summit in both 1974 and 1977. He enjoyed a remarkable eight year peak over that stretch hitting 169 HR (and 140 doubles), averaging over 100 BB, posting an OBP of .391 despite batting .241 and was 231 runs created above average.


INF/OF UT; Eddie Yost (.254/.395/1614/168 RCAA)


With the nickname "The Walking Man," Eddie Yost is a fine final addition to this roster. A relative unknown because he played the bulk of his career with some abysmal Washington Senator teams. He was an offensive standout out of necessity due to the fact that he could man several stations, none of them terribly effectively with mitt in hand. Still, he had excellent power numbers, especially for a right handed hitter playing in the pitcher friendly Griffith Stadium. Over 18 American League campaigns, he hit 337 doubles, 56 triples, and 'touched 'em all' on 139 separate occasions. Between 1950 and 1954 he scored 523 runs, averaged 130 walks (.268 BA/.410 OBP) and enjoyed an RCAA of 132. Yost also enjoyed a brief resurgence in 1959 and 1960 with the Tigers showing atypical power (35 HR....partly thanks to Tiger Stadium) to go along with his usual high walk totals (260). His .269/.425/.417/63 RCAA constituted the second best back-to-back seasons (1950 & 51 being his best) of his career. In all, Yost well earned his nickname, topping 100 walks a grand total of eight times. In those eight years the fewest free passes he totalled was 125 (1960). In 1956 he drew a staggering 151 BB, turning a mediocre .231 hitting mark into an sparkling OBP of .412. For his career he hit .254, drew 1614 walks for (.395 OBP). He also scored 1215 runs and drove in 683. He had a quietly remarkable career finishing atop the league in various offensive categories ten times: OBP (1959, 60), runs (1959), doubles (1951) and walks (1950, 52, 53, 56, 59, 60).


They ain’t the ‘27 (or ‘61, or ‘98) Yankees but with a decent pitching staff behind them I’d be willing to bet they’d be contenders. At the very least, Dusty Baker could blow out four arms in a four game series against them.


Today's link is The Society for American Baseball Research. If you're a baseball junkie, slice open your mouse cord and insert. Hours of ecstacy await.


Best Regards


John


P.S. Care to recommend a baseball web site? Drop me a line!